diff --git a/jasamedika-business/src/main/java/com/jasamedika/medifirst2000/service/impl/LogbookKinerjaServiceImpl.java b/jasamedika-business/src/main/java/com/jasamedika/medifirst2000/service/impl/LogbookKinerjaServiceImpl.java
index 9e4ffc69..02e8d4a5 100644
--- a/jasamedika-business/src/main/java/com/jasamedika/medifirst2000/service/impl/LogbookKinerjaServiceImpl.java
+++ b/jasamedika-business/src/main/java/com/jasamedika/medifirst2000/service/impl/LogbookKinerjaServiceImpl.java
@@ -3031,18 +3031,19 @@ public class LogbookKinerjaServiceImpl extends BaseVoServiceImpl implements Logb
 
 		List<Integer> laboranRadiologList = mapPegawaiLaboratRadiologiDao.findPegawaiLaboranRadiolog();
 		List<Integer> drKsmUmumList = pegawaiDao.getDokterByKelompokKerja(Master.SubUnitKerja.KK_UMUM);
-
+		List<Integer> drLabPAList = pegawaiDao.getDokterByKelompokKerja(Master.SubUnitKerja.KK_PATOLOGI_ANATOMI);
+		List<Integer> drLabPKList = pegawaiDao.getDokterByKelompokKerja(Master.SubUnitKerja.KK_PATOLOGI_KLINIK);
+		List<Integer> drRadList = pegawaiDao.getDokterByKelompokKerja(Master.SubUnitKerja.KK_RADIOLOGI);
 		for (Integer idPegawai : listIdPegawai) {
 			SkorDokterVO skorDokterVO = new SkorDokterVO();
 
-			if (pegawaiDao.getDokterByKelompokKerja(Master.SubUnitKerja.KK_PATOLOGI_ANATOMI).contains(idPegawai)) {
+			if (drLabPAList.contains(idPegawai)) {
 				listDetailJenisProduk = new ArrayList<>(
 						Arrays.asList(Master.DetailJenisProduk.PENUNJANG_PATOLOGI_ANATOMI));
-			} else if (pegawaiDao.getDokterByKelompokKerja(Master.SubUnitKerja.KK_PATOLOGI_KLINIK)
-					.contains(idPegawai)) {
+			} else if (drLabPKList.contains(idPegawai)) {
 				listDetailJenisProduk = new ArrayList<>(
 						Arrays.asList(Master.DetailJenisProduk.PENUNJANG_PATOLOGI_KLINIK));
-			} else if (pegawaiDao.getDokterByKelompokKerja(Master.SubUnitKerja.KK_RADIOLOGI).contains(idPegawai)) {
+			} else if (drRadList.contains(idPegawai)) {
 				listDetailJenisProduk = new ArrayList<>(Arrays.asList(Master.DetailJenisProduk.PENUNJANG_RADIOLOGI));
 			} else {
 				listDetailJenisProduk = new ArrayList<>(Arrays.asList(Master.DetailJenisProduk.MEDIS_UTAMA));